'Nora Barlow' columbine quick facts
About 'Nora Barlow'
'Nora Barlow' belongs to an old group of double, spurless columbines (Aquilegia vulgaris var. stellata) grown in European gardens for centuries. The variety name honors Nora Barlow, a botanist and granddaughter of Charles Darwin who edited his letters and notebooks, a fitting name for a plant so full of variation.
Look closely and the flower is remarkable. The spurs are gone, replaced by dozens of narrow petals packed into a tight, upward-facing pompon. The color changes as it ages and from the base of each petal to the tip: deep rose at the center, white in the middle and green at the ends, so no two flowers look quite alike.
It grows on the same wiry, branching stems as an ordinary Aquilegia vulgaris, with the same lacy blue-green leaves, but stands a little taller, 24-30 in in bloom. That height makes it useful in the middle of a bed, rising through lower plants such as hardy geraniums and lady's mantle.
It is European, not native, and not invasive in the US. Like all columbines it cross-pollinates freely, so seedlings rarely look like the parent: you get singles, doubles and all sorts of colors. To keep true 'Nora Barlow', deadhead it and buy or grow fresh plants from a reliable seed strain every few years. Plant native red columbine elsewhere in the yard if you want to feed spring hummingbirds, since its spurred flowers suit them far better.
Ideal growing conditions
Easy in sun or light shade, as long as the crown stays out of winter-wet soil.
Light
Full sun in northern states; morning sun and afternoon shade in zones 7-8, where midsummer heat can scorch it.
Soil
Average garden soil of almost any type, from clay to alkaline loam. It does not need rich ground.
Moisture
Keep it evenly moist from spring through bloom. After flowering it copes with drier spells.
Drainage
It tolerates heavier, slower soils better than many perennials, but not standing water in winter.
Exposure
The stems are wiry and wind-firm, but a sheltered spot keeps the pompons looking fresh longer.
Hardiness
Hardy to zone 3. Its southern limit is set by heat and humidity, not cold.
Containers
Good in a 2-3 gallon pot for a season or two; plant it out once it has bloomed.
Placement
Mid-bed, where its height shows and later perennials can hide the foliage after it finishes.
Growing 'Nora Barlow' across the US
'Nora Barlow' is hardy in USDA zones 3-8, so cold is rarely an issue; summer heat and leafminers are what to plan for.
Northeast & Midwest
Grows beautifully, blooming from mid-May into June, and one of the few cottage flowers deer tend to skip. Expect columbine leafminer trails by early summer; cutting the foliage back after bloom solves it.
Southeast & Gulf Coast
Best in the upper South (zones 7-8) with afternoon shade and moist soil, flowering in April. Plants often decline in long, humid summers, so treat it as short-lived and replant every couple of years.
Southwest & California
Suited to higher elevations and coastal or Northern California with shade and regular water. In the low desert, choose native golden columbine (Aquilegia chrysantha) instead.
Pacific Northwest
Ideal mild, moist springs. It self-seeds readily here, so deadhead to keep the patch true to 'Nora Barlow'. Native western columbine makes a good hummingbird partner.
Mountain West & Plains
Very cold-hardy and enjoys cool springs at elevation. Give it afternoon shade, shelter from drying wind and water in dry spells. Native Rocky Mountain columbine pairs well.
How to plant 'Nora Barlow'
Pick a mid-bed spot
Choose sun or light shade where its 2 ft height shows and later perennials can grow up around it.
Loosen the soil
Dig in a little compost; rich soil and heavy feeding only make it floppy.
Plant after your last frost
About early May in zone 5 and early April in zone 7, or in early fall at least six weeks before frost. Keep the crown level with the soil surface.
Group three or five plants
Space them 12-18 in apart for a full clump of pompons.
Water through the first season
Keep new plants moist until established; after that they need water only in dry spells.
Looking after 'Nora Barlow'
Water in spring, cut back after bloom, and deadhead to keep it true.
Watering
Keep the soil moist while it grows and flowers, and water in hot, dry spells, especially in the South.
Fertilizing
Little or none. A spring top-dressing of compost is enough.
Cutting back
Once flowering ends, cut the stems back to the leaves. Shear tired or leafminer-marked foliage to the ground for a fresh mound.
Deadheading to keep it true
Remove spent flowers before seed ripens. Its seedlings are cross-pollinated and almost never look like 'Nora Barlow'.
Propagation
Buy new plants or sow seed from a reliable supplier. It has a deep taproot and does not divide or transplant well.
Winter care
Clear old foliage in late fall or early spring. In zones 3-4, a light mulch after the ground freezes protects young plants.
Common problems & how to prevent them
Seedlings that look nothing like the parent
Single flowers and new colors appear.
Prevent: cross-pollination with other columbines. Deadhead 'Nora Barlow', pull off-type seedlings and buy fresh plants to keep the true form.White winding trails in the leaves
Squiggly lines across the foliage.
Prevent: columbine leafminer. Mostly cosmetic. Pick off affected leaves or cut the plant down after bloom for clean regrowth.Leaves stripped to the veins
Foliage eaten away in late spring.
Prevent: columbine sawfly larvae. Check the leaf undersides from mid-spring and pick them off; cut stripped plants back and they will regrow.White film on the leaves
A powdery coating in summer.
Prevent: powdery mildew, worse in dry soil and still air. Water at the base and cut the foliage down after flowering. See our powdery mildew guide.Plants fading after a few years
A clump that thins out.
Prevent: normal for a short-lived perennial, or winter-wet soil. Replant every few years from a reliable source.Companion plants for Aquilegia ‘Nora Barlow’
Partners for the same late-spring moment in sun or light shade.
Alchemilla
Alchemilla mollis
Chartreuse froth at the front of the bed that hides fading columbine leaves.
View profileHardy Geranium 'Johnson's Blue'
Geranium 'Johnson's Blue'
Blue saucers right at the pompons' feet, carrying color on into summer.
View profileAstrantia
Astrantia major
Pincushion flowers in pinks and whites that echo the columbine's colors.
View profilePlants similar to Aquilegia ‘Nora Barlow’
Other cottage favorites for late spring, and how they compare.
Aquilegia
Aquilegia vulgaris
The classic single, spurred columbine in many colors, easier for hummingbirds and bees.
View profileAstrantia
Astrantia major
Pincushion flowers in similar soft pinks, longer flowering.
View profileDicentra
Dicentra formosa
Arching stems of heart-shaped flowers for part shade, a little earlier in spring.
View profileCampanula
Campanula persicifolia
Bellflowers in blues and purples for the same beds, flowering a little later.
View profileWildlife value
Pretty rather than prolific for wildlife; the spurless double flowers are harder for pollinators to use.
Bees
Bumblebees still visit the open double flowers, but there is less easy nectar than in single, spurred columbines.
Syrphid flies
Small flies visit the flowers for pollen, especially on warm spring days.
Foliage & shelter
The low mound of leaves gives cover to ground beetles and other small creatures in the bed.
Hummingbirds
Without spurs it offers little to hummingbirds; grow native red or western columbine nearby for them.
Deer resistant
Deer and rabbits seldom touch it, so it lasts in yards where tulips and hostas are eaten.
'Nora Barlow' columbine - frequently asked questions
What makes 'Nora Barlow' different from ordinary columbine?
Its flowers are double and spurless. Instead of nodding bonnets with long spurs, it has upright pompons of narrow, quilled petals in rose-pink, white and green. The plant, leaves and care are the same as for ordinary European columbine.
Is 'Nora Barlow' deer resistant?
Yes. Like other columbines it is rarely eaten by deer or rabbits, which makes it a good choice for yards with heavy deer pressure.
What zone does 'Nora Barlow' grow in?
USDA zones 3-8. It is very cold-hardy and does best where summers are not too hot and humid. Check your zone with our growing zone finder.
Does 'Nora Barlow' come true from seed?
Not from your own plants. Columbines cross freely, so seedlings are usually a mix of singles and doubles in other colors. Seed from a reliable supplier is grown in isolation and comes much closer to true.
Does 'Nora Barlow' come back every year?
Yes, but each plant lives only three to five years. Replant with fresh plants or reliable seed every few years to keep the variety going.
Where is the best place to plant it?
Mid-bed in full sun in the North, or in morning sun and afternoon shade in warmer zones, in average soil that does not stay wet in winter.
When should I cut it back?
After flowering, cut the flower stems down. If the foliage is tired or marked by leafminers, cut it to the ground and a fresh mound of leaves will grow.
Is it good for bees and hummingbirds?
It is moderately useful for bumblebees but offers little to hummingbirds, because it has no spurs. Add native red columbine nearby if you want to attract spring hummingbirds.
Will it grow in shade?
It does well in part shade and dappled shade under deciduous trees. In deep shade it gets leggy and flowers poorly.
Does it make a good cut flower?
Yes, for small arrangements. Cut stems when the first flowers open and they last several days in a vase.
Is 'Nora Barlow' poisonous?
Columbines contain compounds, mostly in the seeds and roots, that can be harmful if eaten in quantity. Don't eat any part of the plant, and keep children from tasting the seeds.
Related PlantMapper tools & guides
Recommended products
A few practical basics for growing columbines.
Product links go to search results on Amazon.com so you can compare options and prices. PlantMapper USA does not currently earn anything from these links. See our Affiliate Disclosure.
Find your next plant with PlantMapper
'Nora Barlow' is easy almost anywhere in the cooler half of the country, and the right partners make it shine. Tell our free Plant Finder about your zone, light and soil and it will suggest what will thrive.