Mahonia 'Charity' quick facts
About Mahonia 'Charity'
Mahonia × media (now often listed by botanists as Berberis × media) is a hybrid between two Asian mahonias, M. japonica and the frost-tender M. lomariifolia. 'Charity' was the first selection, raised in the 1950s, and it is still the one most nurseries carry, alongside 'Winter Sun' and 'Lionel Fortescue'.
Its value is all in the timing. In zones 7-9 it flowers roughly from November into February, filling a shady corner with scent and color when the rest of the yard is asleep, and for the other months it is a striking, architectural evergreen. In the Pacific Northwest and California it is a favorite winter food source for Anna's hummingbirds, which stay all year there.
The flowers are followed by small blue-black berries with a gray bloom, like tiny grapes, that robins, cedar waxwings and mockingbirds eat. That is the one caution for Southeast gardeners: a close relative, leatherleaf mahonia (Mahonia bealei), has escaped into woodlands across the Southeast and is listed as invasive in several states, and birds spread its seed. 'Charity' itself is not generally listed as invasive, but in the South it is wise to watch for seedlings in nearby woods and pull them.
If you want a native instead, Oregon grape (Mahonia aquifolium), the state flower of Oregon, and the lower creeping mahonia (M. repens) are North American relatives that bloom in spring, hardy far colder than 'Charity'. For a shady winter-flowering native in the East, consider witch hazel (Hamamelis virginiana), which flowers in fall.
© Krzysztof Ziarnek, Kenraiz · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia
Ideal growing conditions
Shade and almost any soil. It is one of the easiest shrubs to place in a shady yard.
Sunlight
Part to full shade is ideal. It grows in sun in the Pacific Northwest, but in most of the US strong sun yellows and scorches the leaves.
Soil
Clay, loam or sand, acidic or alkaline. It is not fussy either way.
Moisture
Average soil is best, but once established it handles the dry shade under trees and along house foundations.
Drainage
Any, including slow, heavy clay. Only truly waterlogged ground is a problem.
Shelter
Cold, drying winter wind can scorch the leaves, especially at the northern edge of its range. A sheltered, shady spot keeps the foliage looking its best.
Space
Allow about 6 ft of width. It is an architectural plant and looks cramped squeezed into a narrow bed.
Position and spines
The leaflets end in real spines. Keep it away from paths, doorways and play areas - or use it as a deterrent along a property line or under a window.
Hardiness
Hardy in USDA zones 7-9 (to about 0°F). In zone 6 it may survive in a very sheltered spot but often gets winter-burned and loses its flower buds. Find your growing zone.
Growing Mahonia 'Charity' across the US
'Charity' is a zone 7-9 shrub, so it belongs mostly to the milder coasts and the South; in colder regions, a native mahonia is the better bet.
Northeast & Midwest
Too cold for most of this region. In sheltered zone 7 spots (coastal New York, Long Island, the Philadelphia and Washington, DC areas) it grows well in shade but may lose its flowers in a hard winter. Further north and inland, choose Oregon grape for the look or witch hazel for winter flowers.
Southeast & Gulf Coast
Grows well in zones 7-9 in shade, and deer leave it alone. Give it shade from hot afternoon sun and water in summer droughts. Because leatherleaf mahonia is invasive in Southeastern forests, pull any mahonia seedlings you find and consider clipping off old flower spikes.
Southwest & California
Good in coastal and Northern California in shade, where its winter flowers feed Anna's hummingbirds. In the hot, dry interior and the desert Southwest it scorches; it needs deep shade and regular water there, and native Oregon grape or creeping mahonia are better choices.
Pacific Northwest
One of its best regions. Mild winters and cool summers suit it perfectly, it takes more sun here than anywhere else, and in Seattle and Portland gardens it is a top winter food plant for resident Anna's hummingbirds. Plant it alongside the native Oregon grape.
Mountain West & Plains
Not hardy enough for most of the region, where winters are colder than 0°F and the air is dry. Grow the native creeping mahonia (Mahonia repens) or Oregon grape instead; both handle cold, dry, alkaline conditions.
How to plant Mahonia 'Charity'
Choose a shaded spot with room
Under high tree canopy, on the north or east side of the house, or in a shady shrub border.
Improve dry soil before planting
Mix in plenty of compost. Dry shade is survivable, but plants establish much faster in improved soil.
Plant in fall or early spring
Fall is best in zones 7-9, giving the roots a mild winter to settle before the first hot summer.
Plant at the same depth and wear gloves
The spines are sharp. Firm in well and water thoroughly.
Mulch and water for two years
A thick mulch and regular deep watering through the first two summers is what gets it established in dry shade.
Looking after Mahonia 'Charity'
Cut the flowered stems back every spring. That one job prevents almost everything that goes wrong with mahonias.
Annual pruning
As the flowers fade in late winter or early spring, cut each flowered stem back by 12 to 24 in, to just above a whorl of leaves. New shoots break from that point, keeping the plant bushy.
Renovation
A leggy old plant can be cut back hard, even to 2 ft, in spring. It regrows from old wood, though it takes a couple of years to look good again.
Watering
First two summers, then only in serious drought - more often in the hot Southeast and inland California.
Mulching
A layer of shredded leaves, pine straw or compost each spring, especially on dry soil under trees.
Feeding
Rarely needed. A balanced slow-release shrub fertilizer in spring if growth is weak on poor ground.
Berries
Leave the berries for the birds - unless you garden near woodland in the Southeast, where clipping off spent flower spikes before berries ripen keeps seedlings out of the woods.
Common problems & how to prevent them
Bare legs with flowers only at the top
A tall bare stem topped by a tuft of leaves.
Prevent: never pruning. Cut the flowered stems back by 12 to 24 in each spring from the start; an old leggy plant can be cut hard and will regrow.Powdery mildew
White coating on the leaves in summer.
Prevent: dry roots and poor air flow. Mulch and water; it is usually cosmetic, not fatal.Rust
Orange-brown spots on the undersides of leaves.
Prevent: a fungal rust that affects mahonias, worse in damp, still conditions. Remove the worst leaves and thin the plant for better air flow.Yellow or scorched leaves
Foliage going pale, yellow-green or brown at the edges.
Prevent: too much sun, especially in hot southern summers, or occasionally poor soil. It is a shade plant; move it or give it more shelter.Frosted flower spikes
Brown flowers after a hard frost.
Prevent: an unusually hard freeze. The plant is usually unharmed and flowers normally the next year; a sheltered site reduces the risk. Repeated damage means it is at the cold edge of its range.Companion plants for Mahonia 'Charity'
Shade-loving evergreens and winter-interest plants for the same bed.
Sweet box
Sarcococca confusa
Powerful winter fragrance at knee height in front of the mahonia, flowering at the same time.
View profileFatsia japonica
Fatsia japonica
Equally bold evergreen leaves for the same shade in zones 7-10, with a completely different leaf shape.
View profileMale fern
Dryopteris filix-mas
Soft green fronds to hide the bare stems mahonias tend to develop. Native Christmas fern does the same job in the East.
View profilePlants similar to Mahonia 'Charity'
Other mahonias and winter-flowering shrubs, and how they compare.
Mahonia x media
Mahonia × media
The wider hybrid group - 'Winter Sun' and 'Lionel Fortescue' are the other two to look for.
View profileOregon grape
Mahonia aquifolium
A lower, spreading North American native, better as shady ground cover, flowering in spring and hardy to about zone 5.
View profileSweet box
Sarcococca confusa
Far smaller, with a stronger scent from tiny flowers - the two work well together.
View profileDaphne 'Jacqueline Postill'
Daphne bholua 'Jacqueline Postill'
A winter daphne with an even stronger scent, but much fussier about drainage and heat.
View profileWildlife value
One of the few useful winter nectar plants in an American yard.
Winter nectar
Bumblebees active on mild winter days, and Anna's hummingbirds on the West Coast, find very little else in flower. This is the plant's greatest wildlife value.
Berries
Blue-black berries in late winter and spring are eaten by American robins, cedar waxwings and mockingbirds.
Shelter
Dense evergreen cover for roosting birds and overwintering insects.
Structure
The spiny interior makes a safe nesting site for small birds in yards with cats.
Deer
Deer and rabbits generally avoid the spiny leaves, which is a big advantage in the Mid-Atlantic and Southeast suburbs.
Mahonia 'Charity' - frequently asked questions
When does Mahonia 'Charity' bloom?
Roughly from November into February in zones 7-9, with the main show around December and January. That timing is the whole point - fragrant yellow flowers in the darkest weeks, on a plant that looks good all year.
How do I stop it getting leggy?
Prune it every year. As the flowers fade in late winter, cut each flowered stem back by 12 to 24 in, to just above a whorl of leaves; new shoots break from there and the plant stays bushy. Skip it and you get a tall bare stem with a tuft on top.
Can I cut an overgrown mahonia back hard?
Yes. It regrows from old wood, so a leggy plant can be cut to about 2 ft in spring. It looks rough for a year and decent after two. Mulch and water after cutting to support the regrowth.
Is Mahonia 'Charity' invasive?
'Charity' (Mahonia x media) is not generally listed as invasive. Its relative leatherleaf mahonia (Mahonia bealei), which is often confused with M. japonica in the trade, has escaped into forests across the Southeast and is on invasive plant lists in several states. Birds spread mahonia seed, so in the Southeast check your state's invasive plant list, pull any seedlings you find, and consider cutting off spent flower spikes. Native alternatives include Oregon grape in the West and witch hazel in the East.
Is Mahonia 'Charity' deer resistant?
Yes. The stiff, spine-tipped leaves put off deer and rabbits, so it is one of the more reliable evergreens for shady yards with heavy deer pressure. Wear thick gloves when pruning, and keep it away from paths and play areas.
What is the difference between 'Charity' and 'Winter Sun'?
Both are Mahonia x media selections and both are excellent. 'Charity' blooms a little earlier with more spreading, arching spikes; 'Winter Sun' is more upright with a slightly stronger fragrance. Either is a good choice, and availability at your garden center usually decides it.
Can I eat the berries?
They are edible but extremely sour and seedy, so not worth eating raw. The native Oregon grape (Mahonia aquifolium) is the species traditionally used for jelly in the Northwest. In practice the berries are best left for the birds.
What zone does Mahonia 'Charity' grow in?
USDA zones 7-9. It takes winter lows to about 0°F, so it suits the Mid-Atlantic, the Southeast, the Pacific Northwest and much of California. In zone 6 it needs a very sheltered spot and may lose its flowers; in colder areas grow Oregon grape instead.
Will it grow in a pot?
Yes, in a large container of good potting mix, and it makes a strong structural plant for a shady patio. It needs regular watering and repotting every few years, and it won't reach the size it would in the ground.
What is the white coating on the leaves?
Powdery mildew, which shows up in dry summers when the roots are short of water and air flow is poor. It is unsightly rather than serious. Mulch, water in drought and thin crowded growth.
Is mahonia poisonous to dogs?
Mahonia is not generally regarded as a poisoning risk for dogs or cats, though, as with any plant, eating a lot of leaves or berries can upset a stomach. The main hazard in a yard with pets or children is the spines.
Related PlantMapper tools & guides
Recommended products
Hand-picked Mahonia 'Charity' growing essentials, chosen on merit.
Product links go to search results on Amazon.com so you can compare options and prices. PlantMapper USA does not currently earn anything from these links. See our Affiliate Disclosure.
Find your next plant with PlantMapper
Winter is when a yard's evergreen structure earns its keep, and shade is where most people run out of ideas. Tell our free Plant Finder about your darkest corner and it will suggest plants that will thrive there.