Soft shield fern quick facts
About soft shield fern
Polystichum setiferum is a European woodland and hedgerow fern, and in American gardens it has earned a place as one of the most elegant evergreen ferns for shade. It belongs to the same genus as two well-loved North American natives: Christmas fern (Polystichum acrostichoides) in the East and western sword fern (Polystichum munitum) on the Pacific coast.
The name says it all: run your hand along a frond and it feels soft, with each tiny segment ending in a flexible bristle rather than a prickle. The fronds are much more finely divided than Christmas fern's, giving a lacy, almost feathery look. Fern collectors have selected many forms, from the extra-lacy Divisilobum and Plumosum types to 'Herrenhausen', a compact, popular nursery variety.
Its practical gift is toughness. Once its roots are down, it keeps decent fronds through dry spells in the root-filled soil under maples and oaks, where many ferns crisp up. It also tolerates alkaline, limestone-based soil, which makes it useful in the Midwest and parts of Texas and the Plains where acid-loving ferns sulk.
It is not invasive and isn't a known problem anywhere in the US. If you want a native fern instead, Christmas fern is a superb substitute in the eastern half of the country, and western sword fern is the classic choice from northern California to Alaska. Both are evergreen and deer resistant too.
© Ermell · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia
Ideal growing conditions
Shade, shelter and good drainage. It is far less fussy about moisture than most ferns.
Sunlight
Part to full shade. Morning sun is fine in the North; in the South and West, midday and afternoon sun scorches the fronds.
Soil
Loam or clay with shredded leaves or compost worked in. Unlike many ferns, it is happy in neutral to alkaline soil.
Moisture
Evenly moist soil gives the lushest plant, but an established clump tolerates dry shade.
Drainage
Well drained. A crown sitting in cold, wet soil all winter is the thing most likely to kill it.
Shelter
Wind shreds the soft fronds. A spot near a wall, fence or shrubs keeps it looking good, especially through winter.
Hardiness
USDA zones 5-8. Evergreen in zones 6-8; in zone 5 the fronds may brown in winter but the crown regrows. Find your growing zone.
Under trees
One of the few ferns that performs in dry, root-filled soil under deciduous trees, once established.
Space
Allow about 30 in. A mature vase of fronds is wider than most people expect.
Growing soft shield fern across the US
Hardy in USDA zones 5-8, it does best where summers are not too hot and winters are not too harsh.
Northeast & Midwest
A good shade plant for zones 5-7, and a real asset where deer strip hostas. Plant it out of winter wind, mulch well, and pair it with native Christmas fern, which is the tougher choice in zone 4.
Southeast & Gulf Coast
Grows well in zones 7-8 in the Piedmont and mountains given full shade and steady moisture. Steamy Gulf Coast heat is a struggle; native Christmas fern and Japanese shield fern (Dryopteris erythrosora) are more reliable there.
Southwest & California
Possible in shady, irrigated gardens in coastal and northern California. Too hot and dry for the low deserts. Native western sword fern is the natural choice for California shade.
Pacific Northwest
Its ideal US climate: mild, moist winters and cool summers. It thrives under Douglas fir and bigleaf maple alongside native sword fern, and slugs rarely bother it.
Mountain West & Plains
Worth trying in sheltered, shaded spots in zone 5-6 towns. Dry wind and intense sun are the enemies, so use the north side of a building and water during dry spells.
How to plant soft shield fern
Choose shady, sheltered ground
The north side of the house, under shrubs or trees, or a shaded corner by a fence. Avoid open sun and wind.
Add organic matter
Work in leaf mold, shredded leaves or compost. It helps the fern establish even in soil that later dries out.
Plant in spring or early fall
Spring after your last frost is ideal; early fall works in zones 7-8, at least six weeks before the ground freezes.
Keep the crown at soil level
Never bury the crown. Set the top of the root ball level with the surrounding soil.
Water through two summers
Drought tolerance comes with age. Water regularly until it is established, especially in hot spells.
Caring for soft shield fern
One real job: cut off last year's fronds in late winter, before the new fiddleheads unroll.
The late-winter trim
Just before the fiddleheads open (March in zone 7, April in zone 5), cut every old frond off at the base. Skip it and the new fronds tangle with brown ones all season.
Mulch
Spread shredded leaves or fine bark mulch each spring to keep the roots cool and feed the soil slowly.
Watering
Regularly for the first two years, then only during long droughts or heat waves.
Fertilizing
Not needed. Rich fertilizer makes soft, floppy fronds. Mulch does the job.
Bulbils
On bulbil-bearing forms, pin a frond onto a tray of moist potting mix in late summer, and each little bud along the midrib roots into a new fern.
Dividing
Rarely needed. Lift and split a large clump in spring if you want more plants.
Common problems & how to prevent them
Messy, brown clump in summer
Fresh fronds lost among old brown ones.
Prevent: last year's fronds weren't removed. Cut them all off at the base next late winter and the difference is dramatic.Scorched, bleached fronds
Pale, crispy foliage, often on the sunny side.
Prevent: too much sun, especially hot afternoon sun in the South and West. Move it in early fall or give it shade from a shrub or tree.Torn, ragged fronds
Shredded tips after storms or winter wind.
Prevent: wind exposure. The soft fronds tear easily. Plant it somewhere sheltered.Crown rotted over winter
The plant gone or mushy at the base in spring.
Prevent: waterlogged soil or a buried crown. Replant on a slight mound in well-drained soil, crown at the surface.Small ferns popping up nearby
Baby ferns in sidewalk cracks and nearby pots.
Prevent: spores. Harmless, and free plants if you want them. Pot them up or pull them.Companion plants for soft shield fern
Shade partners that bring flowers and bold leaves to contrast with the lacy fronds.
Hosta
Hosta
Broad leaves that set off fine fronds perfectly, though deer love hostas, so protect them.
View profileHeuchera
Heuchera sanguinea
Native coral bells: colorful leaves and hummingbird flowers at the front of the bed.
View profileEpimedium
Epimedium × rubrum
Another dry-shade survivor, carpeting the ground beneath it, and deer resistant too.
View profilePlants similar to soft shield fern
Other shade ferns, and how they compare.
Male Fern
Dryopteris filix-mas
Tough and upright, native to parts of North America too, but it dies back in winter.
View profileHart's Tongue Fern
Asplenium scolopendrium
Glossy, undivided straps; another evergreen that likes limestone soil.
View profileJapanese Painted Fern
Athyrium niponicum
Silver and burgundy color, but deciduous and much thirstier.
View profileLady Fern
Athyrium filix-femina
A delicate native fern for moist shade; deciduous and unhappy in dry soil.
View profileWildlife value
Evergreen cover at ground level, the layer most suburban yards are missing.
Winter shelter
The evergreen fronds shelter beetles, spiders and overwintering insects after perennials have died back.
Ground-feeding birds
American robins, thrushes, towhees and juncos scratch through the leaf litter under fern clumps for insects.
Amphibians
American toads, frogs and salamanders use the cool, damp shade under the fronds as a daytime hideout.
Deer-proof cover
Because deer and rabbits ignore it, it keeps providing cover in yards where browsing strips everything else.
Non-toxic
Not known to be toxic to people, dogs, cats or horses.
Soft shield fern: frequently asked questions
Does soft shield fern really grow in dry shade?
Better than most ferns, but only once established. Plant it with plenty of organic matter and water it through its first two summers. After that it holds good fronds through dry spells under trees, where lady fern or painted fern would brown.
What zone does soft shield fern grow in?
USDA zones 5-8. It stays evergreen in zones 6-8; in zone 5 the fronds may brown over winter, but the crown regrows in spring. It struggles in the hot, humid Gulf Coast and the low deserts.
Is soft shield fern deer resistant?
Yes. Deer and rabbits leave ferns like this alone, which makes it one of the most reliable shade plants in deer country.
Is it native to North America?
No, it is European. Its closest native relatives are Christmas fern (Polystichum acrostichoides) in the East and western sword fern (Polystichum munitum) in the West. Both are evergreen, deer resistant and excellent substitutes.
When do I cut the old fronds off?
In late winter, just before the new fiddleheads unroll: about March in zone 7, April in zone 5. Cut every old frond to the base. It feels drastic on an evergreen, but it makes the plant look fresh all year.
Will it grow in alkaline soil?
Yes, which is unusual for a fern. In the wild it often grows on limestone, so it is a good choice for neutral to alkaline soils in the Midwest and other limestone regions.
Can I make more plants from it?
Easily, with a bulbil-bearing form. In late summer, look for tiny plantlets along the frond midrib, pin the frond onto a tray of moist potting mix, and each bulbil roots into a new fern over the following months.
How big does it get?
Usually 2-3 ft tall and wide, forming a broad vase of fronds. Give it about 30 in of space rather than squeezing it into a gap.
Can I grow it in a container?
Yes, it makes a handsome pot plant for a shady porch. Use potting mix with added compost, keep it out of direct sun and water more often than in the ground. In zone 5-6 winters, move the pot to an unheated garage.
Do I need to fertilize it?
No. Ferns dislike rich feeding, which produces soft, floppy fronds. A yearly mulch of shredded leaves or compost gives it everything it needs.
Will slugs eat it?
Rarely. Ferns are among the few shade plants slugs and snails mostly ignore, which makes them invaluable in the Pacific Northwest and other damp areas. New fiddleheads may get nibbled in a wet spring, but mature fronds are left alone.
Related PlantMapper tools & guides
Recommended products
Simple supplies for a healthy shade bed.
Product links go to search results on Amazon.com so you can compare options and prices. PlantMapper USA does not currently earn anything from these links. See our Affiliate Disclosure.
Find your next plant with PlantMapper
Dry shade under trees is the hardest spot in most yards. Tell our free Plant Finder your zone, soil and light, and it will suggest plants that genuinely cope with it.