Cedar, Treated Lumber, Steel, Block and Stone Compared
The material decides three things: what the planter costs, how long it lasts, and whether it looks like part of the house or part of the vegetable garden. Nearly everything else, such as how well plants grow and how often you water, comes down to size and soil rather than what the walls are made of.
General advice for American yards. Never use old creosote-treated railroad ties for planters that grow food or sit where children play. Keep the soil in any planter built against the house well below the siding (codes generally want at least 6 in between soil and wood siding), and in termite country keep wood off direct soil contact where you can. Part of the PlantMapper Raised Planters section.
Wood is the default for good reasons, but it is not the only answer · photograph via Pexels
How to choose
Three questions decide the material
Ignore the catalog photos for a moment. The choice comes down to how long you want it to last, how much you want to spend, and whether you are building it yourself.
A treated-lumber planter costs a fraction of a brick one and may need replacing in ten to fifteen years. A brick or stone planter will outlast you, but it needs a mason and a footing. Everything else sits between those two extremes, and there is no wrong answer, only a mismatch between what you built and how long you wanted it to last.
The one real constraint is shape. Boards, landscape timbers and most concrete products cannot follow a curve. If the design has curves, you are choosing between galvanized or Corten steel, stucco over block, brick and stone before you consider anything else.
At a glance
The materials compared
Very rough US prices per linear foot of planter wall, materials only, for a wall about 2 ft high. Prices vary a lot by region and change often.
Raised planter materials compared. Lifespans are rough and depend on climate, termites and ground contact.
Material
Cost / ft
Life
Build difficulty
Best for
Pressure-treated lumber (ground contact)
$3 to $8
10 to 20 yrs
Low
The default. Vegetable planters, quick builds, any straight-sided shape
Treated landscape timbers (6x6)
$4 to $8
10 to 20 yrs
Low, but heavy work
Chunky, solid planters; each course adds about 5½ in of height
Cedar, redwood or cypress
$6 to $18
10 to 20 yrs+
Moderate
A natural-wood planter with no chemical treatment
Reclaimed lumber / pallets
$0 to $5
3 to 8 yrs
Low
Cheap, informal, first attempts and community garden plots
Composite boards
$10 to $20
20 to 25 yrs
Low to moderate
No maintenance, matching an existing composite deck
Corten weathering steel
$20 to $50
25 yrs+
Low, usually bought as a kit
Contemporary design, sharp lines, curves
Galvanized or powder-coated steel
$8 to $25
15 to 30 yrs
Low, usually a bolt-together kit
Modern yards, rooftop decks, light weight, curves and ovals
Brick
$15 to $35
50 yrs+
High, usually a mason’s job
Matching the house, curves, permanence
Stucco over block
$12 to $25
40 yrs+
Moderate to high
Southwest and Mediterranean-style homes, painted finishes, curves
Natural stone
$25 to $60
Permanent
High
Traditional and rural yards, New England and hill-country looks
Concrete block or gabion
$8 to $20
30 yrs+
Moderate
Structural, modern, or where local stone can fill the baskets
Whatever you choose, the soil is a separate and often bigger cost. An 8 x 4 ft planter filled 2 ft deep needs about 64 cubic feet (about 2.4 cubic yards) of mix, which can easily cost more than the lumber. Price both together before deciding. See cost and quantities.
The default choice
Lumber in detail
Wood is used for the great majority of raised planters, and with good reason: it is affordable, easy to cut, forgiving of a first attempt and looks right in nearly any yard. The differences between types matter more than most people realize.
Pressure-treated lumber
The standard home-center choice. Pressure-treated Southern yellow pine or fir in 2x boards (1½ in thick), usually 2x6, 2x8, 2x10 or 2x12, screwed to 4x4 corner posts.
The one spec that matters is the rating on the tag. Buy lumber marked Ground Contact (often UC4A on the end tag), which is made for wood touching soil. Lumber labeled Above Ground looks identical on the rack but is meant for deck boards and railings, and it rots years sooner against wet soil. The price difference is small; the difference in life is large.
Thicker is much better. A 1-in (actually ¾ in) board will bow outward under wet soil and give out in a few years; a 2x board stays flat and lasts. If the choice is between thicker boards and a bigger planter, choose thicker boards.
Life: about 10 to 20 years rated for ground contact. Cost: roughly $3 to $8 per linear foot of wall. Upkeep: none essential; a coat of exterior stain or sealer on the outside only helps it last. Use hot-dip galvanized or coated exterior screws, because modern copper-based treatments corrode plain steel.
Landscape timbers and railroad ties
Treated 6x6 landscape timbers stack like logs: each course adds about 5½ in, so three or four courses make a comfortable 16 to 22 in planter. They are solid, chunky and about as forgiving as building gets, but they are heavy, and an 8 ft 6x6 is a real two-person lift.
Courses are drilled and pinned with long timber screws or lengths of rebar driven through, staggered at the corners like brickwork. Brush a cut-end preservative on every cut, because the middle of a timber is not fully treated and that is where rot starts. Check the tag says ground contact.
Never use old creosote-treated railroad ties for growing food. Creosote is a restricted-use pesticide in the US and is not meant for gardens, food growing or play areas, and old ties ooze tar in summer heat. New ties sold for landscaping are a different product; check how they were treated before using them near edibles.
Life: about 10 to 20 years for treated timbers. Cost: roughly $4 to $8 per linear foot of wall. See the full Landscape Timbers section.
Cedar, redwood and other rot-resistant woods
Western red cedar, redwood and cypress resist rot and insects naturally, with no chemical treatment, which makes them the favorite choice for anyone uneasy about treated lumber around food. They weather to a soft silver-gray within a couple of years and look great doing it.
The trade-offs are cost and durability. Cedar and redwood cost about two to three times as much as treated pine, and it is the dark heartwood that resists rot; lighter sapwood and cheap "fence-grade" cedar rot much faster. Rough-sawn boards can shrink and open small gaps at the corners in the first summer, which does not weaken the planter but is a good reason to line the inside walls.
Where termites are heavy (much of the South and Southeast, Hawaii and parts of California), even cedar will eventually be eaten if it sits on soil. Set it on a gravel or concrete-block base, or choose ground-contact treated lumber or steel.
Life: about 10 to 20 years or more, depending on the grade and your climate. Cost: roughly $6 to $18 per linear foot of wall. Upkeep: none.
Reclaimed lumber and pallets
Reclaimed boards, old fence pickets, leftover deck boards and pallet wood all work for informal planters where a short life is fine, and they can cost nothing.
They are usually untreated, so against soil expect three to eight years rather than fifteen. Lining the inside walls makes a real difference. Pull out old nails and brush off grit before cutting, because both are hard on saw blades.
Two cautions on reclaimed material. Avoid anything that smells of tar or chemicals, and avoid old painted wood, which may have lead paint, especially from homes built before 1978. If you cannot tell what a piece of reclaimed wood was treated with, do not use it for food.
Life: about 3 to 8 years. Cost: roughly $0 to $5 per linear foot, often free.
As an Amazon Associate, PlantMapper may earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are set by Amazon. Use lumber rated for ground contact for anything touching soil, and treat every cut end before the boards go together.
The permanent options
Block, brick and stone
Masonry planters are a different kind of project: more expensive, often a job for a mason, and effectively permanent. They are worth it when the planter is doing architectural work as well as growing plants.
Brick
The best match for a brick house
A brick planter that matches or complements the house looks as though it was always there, and it is the only material that reliably does that. In cold-winter regions use brick graded for severe weathering (often marked SW), or it will spall after a few freeze-thaw winters.
Needs a concrete footing, wider than the wall; in cold regions your local code may want it below the frost line, which ranges from a few inches in the South to 4 ft or more in the northern states.
A single wythe (one brick thick) is fine up to about 18 in; above that build two wythes or add pilasters.
Line the inside face, because permanently wet soil against brick causes staining and white efflorescence.
Cap the top with a rowlock course, a precast cap or flat stone to shed water.
Roughly $15 to $35 per linear foot in materials; usually a mason’s job.
Stucco over block
Smooth modern finishes, lower cost than brick
Concrete block laid up and finished with stucco, then painted, giving crisp planters in any color. It is the classic look for Southwest, Spanish and Mediterranean-style homes, cheaper than brick per foot, quicker to build, and it curves easily.
Still needs a proper concrete footing.
Use an exterior stucco system and finish it with elastomeric or masonry paint.
Line the inside, because stucco fails quickly with wet soil against the back of it.
Repainting every five to eight years keeps it looking new.
Roughly $12 to $25 per linear foot in materials.
Natural stone
Traditional, beautiful, expensive
Dry-laid or mortared fieldstone suits farmhouse, cottage and rural yards like nothing else, and it is effectively permanent. Local stone, such as New England fieldstone, Pennsylvania flagstone or Texas limestone, always looks more at home than stone trucked in from far away.
Dry-laid stone drains freely and can be built without a footing at modest heights, on a compacted gravel base.
Mortared stone needs a footing and a skilled hand.
Very heavy: check what the ground, and any deck or roof beneath, will carry.
Salvaged stone is often cheaper and looks better than new.
Roughly $25 to $60 per linear foot in materials.
Concrete block & gabion
Structural and unfussy
Plain concrete block makes a cheap, strong planter that can be stuccoed, faced, painted or left as it is; split-face retaining wall block stacks with no mortar. Gabion baskets filled with stone give a modern look and cope well with sloping or shifting ground.
Block is the cheapest truly permanent structure.
Gabions need no footing and drain freely, but the wire must be heavy galvanized or PVC-coated.
Line a gabion planter or the soil will wash out through the stone.
Both suit modern designs and sloping yards.
Roughly $8 to $20 per linear foot in materials.
The contemporary option
Metal planters
Galvanized steel planters have become hugely popular in American yards, and unlike most trends they are genuinely practical: thin walls mean more soil in the same footprint, kits bolt together in an afternoon, and metal is the easy way to get curves and ovals.
✓Where metal works well
Corten weathering steel forms a stable rust patina and then stops corroding. No painting, ever.
Galvanized steel and powder-coated aluminum are light enough for rooftop decks and balconies.
Thin walls mean a metal planter holds noticeably more soil than a wooden one of the same outside size.
Rounds, ovals and tapered shapes are easy to buy as kits.
Nothing for termites to eat and nothing to rot, so 15 to 30 years with little upkeep.
Modular kits bolt together on site, which suits awkward access through a side gate.
!What to watch for
Corten stains everything below it orange for the first year or two. Never set it directly on light concrete or pavers without a tray or gravel border.
Dark metal in full sun gets hot, and in desert or Southern summers roots against a south- or west-facing wall can cook. Line the sunny sides with rigid foam board or bubble insulation, or choose a light color.
Thin sheet steel bows under wet soil unless it is braced or ribbed. Check the gauge before buying the cheapest kit.
Cut edges are sharp. Anything at a child's height needs a rolled or capped rim.
Galvanized coatings eventually fail at cut edges and scratches; touch them up with cold galvanizing paint.
Corten and custom steel cost more per foot, though a kit needs no skilled labor.
Line any dark metal planter on its sunny sides. A sheet of bubble insulation or rigid foam board against the inside wall evens out the temperature swings, and in hot-summer regions it is the difference between plants that thrive and plants that struggle.
Low maintenance and second-hand materials
Composite and reclaimed options
Two quite different things get lumped together here: manufactured composite boards, and genuinely reused materials. Both have a place.
Composite and reclaimed materials for raised planters.
Material
What it is
Strengths
Watch for
Wood-plastic composite
Wood fiber and recycled plastic, sold as decking or planter boards
No rot, no splinters, no painting, not eaten by termites; 20 to 25 years; consistent color
Needs a wood or metal frame for strength; expands and contracts with heat; cheap grades fade
Recycled plastic lumber
Solid boards from recycled polymer
Completely rot-proof and termite-proof; long life; often made from post-consumer plastic
Flexes more than wood, so needs closer post spacing; can look plasticky
Recycled plastic landscape timbers
Timber-profile boards made from recycled plastic
The chunky timber look with none of the treatment questions; heavy and stable
Costs more than wood; limited colors
Reclaimed lumber
Old fence boards, deck boards, barn wood
Cheap, often free, full of character
Usually untreated; line it; pull nails; avoid lead paint
Reclaimed brick or stone
Salvaged masonry
Often cheaper and better-looking than new; weathered from day one
Must stand up to freezing in cold regions; mixed sizes make laying slower
Pallet wood
Dismantled pallets
Free
Thin and short-lived; look for the HT (heat treated) stamp and avoid MB (methyl bromide) pallets
IBC totes and stock tanks
Repurposed totes and galvanized livestock tanks
Cheap to very cheap; instant large volume
Galvanized stock tanks are a popular ready-made planter (drill drain holes). Only use totes that held food-grade contents, never one that held chemicals
With any reclaimed material meant for growing food, the rule is simple: if you do not know what it held or what it was treated with, do not use it for edibles. Use it for flowers and ornamental plantings instead, where the question does not arise.
Growing food safely
Materials, treatments and edible crops
This comes up constantly, and the answer is more reassuring than the internet suggests, with two real exceptions.
Modern treated lumber is widely considered acceptable for food
Pressure-treated lumber sold for home use today uses copper-based preservatives (ACQ or copper azole). The arsenic-based CCA treatment was phased out for residential use at the end of 2003.
Many extension services consider modern treated lumber acceptable for raised beds and planters that grow food. If you would still rather not, line the inside walls with a permeable landscape fabric, or use cedar, redwood or galvanized steel, which need no treatment at all.
Creosote is the real exception
Creosote-treated wood, above all old railroad ties, is not meant for gardens, food growing or play areas. It oozes tar in hot weather, stains everything and smells.
Be wary of any old treated lumber of unknown history, including pre-2004 lumber that may be CCA-treated. Clean, untreated reclaimed wood is a different matter and is fine.
Be careful with unknown reclaimed material
Old painted wood may carry lead paint. Industrial totes and drums may have held anything. Pallets marked MB were fumigated with methyl bromide and should be avoided; look for the HT heat-treatment stamp instead.
Where the history is unknown, use the material for ornamentals and grow your food in something you can vouch for.
Line masonry and metal, for their sake and yours
Lining a brick, stucco or metal planter protects the structure from permanently wet soil and stops staining and efflorescence. It is about the planter rather than the plants.
Never line the bottom in a way that seals it. The liner goes up the walls, not across the bottom. See lining a planter.
Watch sharp edges and stability where children play
Round over wooden corners at head height, cap cut metal edges, and make sure nothing can be pulled over. A tall, narrow planter on a patio tips more easily than it looks.
Check the inside walls for screw points poking through as well as the outside, because that is where hands go.
Making the decision
Which material suits your situation
Match the row to your situation rather than to the photo you liked.
Choosing a raised planter material by situation.
If this is you
Choose
Why
First planter, growing vegetables, sensible budget
Ground-contact treated lumber or cedar, 2x boards
Cheapest route to a good result; easy to build; ten years or more
You want chunky and solid without much skill
Treated 6x6 landscape timbers
Four courses give about 22 in; nearly impossible to build badly; very heavy
Uneasy about treated lumber near food
Cedar, redwood or galvanized steel
No chemical treatment; cedar weathers beautifully, steel lasts
Modern yard, crisp lines or curves
Galvanized, powder-coated or Corten steel
Thin walls, sharp shapes, little upkeep; curves without a mason
You want it to match the house and last forever
Brick or stone on a concrete footing
Nothing else looks as settled; fifty years plus; usually needs a mason
Rooftop deck or balcony
Powder-coated aluminum or lightweight composite
Weight is the limit. Check what the structure will carry before anything else
Farmhouse, cottage or rural yard
Fieldstone or cedar
Local materials always look right
Tight budget, informal setting
Reclaimed lumber or a galvanized stock tank
A fraction of the cost; shorter life; genuine character
Termite country, and you never want to maintain it again
Galvanized steel, composite or block
Nothing for termites to eat, no painting, twenty years plus
Sloping or shifting ground
Gabions or retaining wall block
Structural, drains freely, copes with movement
Masonry planters read as architecture rather than as containersThicker boards stay flat; thin ones bow under wet soilCedar and ground-contact treated lumber remain the sensible defaults for growing food
Avoid these
Six material mistakes
Each of these is easy to avoid at the store and expensive to fix afterward.
1. Buying Above Ground lumber for soil contact
Lumber rated only for above-ground use looks identical to ground-contact lumber on the rack, costs a little less, and rots years sooner where it touches wet soil.
The fixRead the end tag and buy lumber marked Ground Contact (often UC4A). The price difference is small, and it can add years to the planter.
2. Using thin boards
A 1-in board (really ¾ in) bows outward under 2 ft of wet soil within a season or two, and once it bows the corners start to open.
The fixUse 2x lumber (1½ in thick), add a post every 3 ft along long sides, and put a cross-brace across the top of anything wider than about 4 ft.
3. Using old creosote railroad ties
They are not meant for gardens, food growing or play areas, ooze tar in summer heat and ruin anything they touch.
The fixUse treated 6x6 landscape timbers, cedar or recycled plastic timbers instead, and avoid any old treated wood of unknown history near edibles.
4. Building masonry without a footing
Brick, block and mortared stone crack and lean when built straight onto soil, because the ground moves with the seasons and frost, and the wall cannot.
The fixPour a proper concrete footing, wider than the wall and as deep as your local code and frost depth require, and let it cure before building on it.
5. Choosing a material that cannot make the shape
People fall for a curved design and then discover that boards, landscape timbers and most concrete products will not curve.
The fixSettle the shape first. Curves mean steel, stucco over block, brick or stone; everything else is straight lines.
6. Setting Corten or new redwood on light paving
Corten runs orange rust for the first year or two, and redwood and cedar can bleed tannin stains when wet. On light concrete or pavers the marks can be hard to remove.
The fixSet the planter on feet with a gravel border, or plan for the staining. It is much easier to allow for than to remove.
Print it or check it off as you go
The buying checklist
Twelve things to settle before you order anything. Your checks are saved in this browser only.
Before you order
Specification
Safety and finish
Questions
Raised planter materials: your questions answered
Answers to the questions homeowners ask most.
What is the best material for a raised planter?
For most people, ground-contact pressure-treated lumber or cedar in 2x boards (1½ in thick). It is an affordable route to a good result, easy to build without special skills, and lasts ten years or more. Choose differently when you have a reason: cedar, redwood or galvanized steel if you would rather avoid treated lumber near food, steel for modern shapes and curves, brick or stone to match the house and last for decades, and lightweight aluminum or composite on a rooftop deck where weight matters. In heavy termite areas, steel, composite or block outlast wood.
Is pressure-treated lumber safe for a vegetable planter?
Modern pressure-treated lumber sold for home use uses copper-based preservatives (ACQ or copper azole), and many extension services consider it acceptable for raised beds and planters that grow food. The arsenic-based CCA treatment was phased out for residential use at the end of 2003, so be wary of old lumber of unknown age. If you would still rather not use it, line the inside walls with a permeable landscape fabric or use cedar, redwood or galvanized steel. The real exception is creosote: never use old creosote-treated railroad ties for growing food.
Can I use railroad ties or landscape timbers for a raised planter?
Treated 6x6 landscape timbers are excellent for planters: solid, forgiving to build with, and each course adds about 5½ in of height. Check the tag says ground contact. Old railroad ties are a different matter: most were treated with creosote, which is not meant for gardens, food growing or play areas, and they ooze tar in hot weather. Recycled plastic timbers give the same chunky look with none of the treatment questions. The Landscape Timbers section covers this in full.
How long does a wooden raised planter last?
Ground-contact pressure-treated lumber typically gives ten to twenty years, and thick 2x boards last much longer than thin ones. Above Ground rated lumber, which looks identical, may manage only a few years against wet soil. Cedar and redwood heartwood last ten to twenty years or more untreated, less where termites are heavy, and reclaimed or untreated pine gives three to eight. Lining the inside walls adds several years to any of them, because it keeps permanently wet soil off the wood.
Are metal raised planters too hot for plants?
They can be on the sunny side, especially in Southern and desert summers: a dark metal planter facing south or west can heat the soil against its wall enough to stunt roots. The fix is simple and cheap: line the inside of the sunny walls with bubble insulation or rigid foam board before filling. Light-colored and plain galvanized finishes heat far less than dark powder coating or Corten, and a planter shaded for part of the afternoon is rarely a problem.
Do brick or block planters need a footing?
Yes. Brick, block and mortared stone all need a concrete footing, wider than the wall and on firm ground, and in cold regions your local code may want it below the frost line. Without it the wall cracks and leans as the ground freezes, thaws and shifts, often within the first few winters. That is the main reason masonry planters are usually a mason’s job rather than a weekend project. Dry-laid stone and mortarless retaining wall block on a compacted gravel base are the exceptions at modest heights, because they can flex.
What is the cheapest way to build a raised planter?
Reclaimed lumber, old fence boards or a galvanized stock tank with drain holes drilled in the bottom. Reclaimed wood can be free, though it is usually untreated, so expect three to eight years and line the inside walls. Among new materials, ground-contact treated 2x lumber is the cheapest. Remember that the soil to fill any planter is often the bigger cost, so saving on the box may matter less than you expect.
Can I use composite decking boards for a planter?
Yes, and they make excellent planters: no rot, no splinters, no painting, nothing for termites to eat, and twenty to twenty-five years of life. Two things to allow for: composite boards are not structural, so they need a wood or metal frame behind them to carry the weight of the soil, and they expand and contract with temperature more than wood, so leave the gaps the manufacturer recommends at the ends. They are the obvious choice if you already have a composite deck and want the planters to match.