1. Ignoring one lifted section
It snags the mower, the mower pushes it further, and within two seasons the whole run is wandering.
The fixDeal with a raised section the week you spot it. At that stage it is a two-minute job.
Good edging is close to set-and-forget, but not quite. Winter frost nudges it up, summer heat makes plastic wander, and Bermudagrass is always looking for a way over the top. Catch one lifted piece in spring and it is a two-minute fix; ignore it and by fall the whole run is wavy. Here is the yearly routine, care for each material, the eight problems you are likely to see and the point where replacing beats repairing.
General guidance for American yards. If an edge that also holds back soil or a slope has shifted, get advice before you dig it out, and call 811 before driving new stakes deeper than the old ones. Part of the PlantMapper Landscape Edging section.
Most edging really does look after itself. The trouble is that small movements snowball. One stake loosens over the winter, that section rises a little, the mower clips it, it rises further, and a couple of seasons later sixty feet of edge is wandering instead of one board.
The cure is a single walk along every edge each spring, as soon as the ground has thawed and before new growth hides the line, carrying a rubber mallet and a few spare stakes. Tap down anything proud, restake anything loose, and trim back grass that has crept over. For steel, aluminum, composite, wood and precast concrete, that really is the whole job.
How much work you get depends on where you live. In the North and the Mountain West, frost heave is the main enemy and spring is when you see the damage. In the South, there is little frost, but warm-season grasses like Bermudagrass, zoysia and St. Augustine creep relentlessly all summer. Brick, pavers and stone ask for a little more: the joints and base give out long before the material, so expect to reset the odd piece every decade.
Timing follows your climate, not the calendar. Two moments matter; the rest is as-you-notice. Find your growing zone if you are not sure which applies.
| When | What to do | How long |
|---|---|---|
| Early spring, once the ground thaws (about March in zones 6-7, April to May in zones 3-5, late winter in zones 8-10) | The main check. Walk every run with a mallet. Tap down anything frost has lifted, drive new stakes where old ones are loose, note anything that has drifted | 20-30 minutes |
| Spring, as the lawn greens up | Trim grass that has grown over a flush edge; sweep soil, mulch and winter grit off a mow strip | Half an hour |
| Through the mowing season | Nothing scheduled. Push down anything the mower catches when you notice it | Minutes |
| Mid to late summer | Cut back Bermudagrass, zoysia or St. Augustine runners going over or under the edge into beds - every few weeks in the South | 15 minutes |
| Fall | Rake leaves away from the edge, especially off a mow strip where they stain and grow moss; check stakes before the ground freezes | 15 minutes |
| Winter (cold zones) | Keep snowblowers and plow blades off edging along walks and driveways; use sand or calcium magnesium acetate instead of rock salt next to metal and concrete edging where you can | None |
| Every 5-10 years | Reset or repoint the odd brick, paver or stone; replace any wood board that has gone soft; reseal colored concrete curbing | A morning |
| Whenever it needs it | Recut a spade-cut edge with a half-moon edger - two or three times a season if you have no hard edging | 20 minutes a session |
Do the main check as soon as the ground thaws. Every edge is visible, the soil is soft enough to drive a stake without a fight, frost damage from the winter is plain to see, and anything you fix is solid before mowing starts. Doing it in July through a full flower bed takes three times as long and you miss half of it.
Brief, because most of these need very little.
The lowest-maintenance edging you can buy. Little to do beyond the spring walk-around.
Needs less attention than a deck or fence, because it is small and cheap to replace.
The material lasts for decades. The joints, the base and the restraint behind it don't.
Composite needs nothing. Thin roll plastic needs more attention than any other edging, which is worth knowing before you buy it.
Not every bed needs a product. A clean spade-cut edge (sometimes called a natural or English edge) costs nothing, follows any curve, and done well it looks better than most plastic on the shelf. It just has to be redone.
A flat-bladed half-moon edger gives a clean straight face where a round shovel gives a scalloped one. Work backward along the line so you never stand on the edge you have just cut. A powered bed edger does the same job faster on long runs.
A straight 2x4 for straight runs, a garden hose for curves. Edging by eye drifts, and it drifts a little further each year until the bed has changed shape.
A clean vertical cut on the lawn side, about 3-4 inches deep, and 2 inches or so of bare soil sloping back into the bed. That little trench is what stops grass runners crossing.
Sod pieces left in the bed root and grow, especially Bermudagrass. Pick them up and compost them or put them in the yard waste.
A string trimmer turned on its side, an edging shear or a stick edger every few weeks keeps the line crisp between full recuts.
A cut edge is free and looks great but needs doing a few times a season, forever. Hard edging costs money once and then mostly leaves you alone. Neither is wrong - just know which deal you are choosing. With Bermudagrass or zoysia, a hard edge usually wins.
As an Amazon Associate, PlantMapper may earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are set by Amazon. A spade-cut edge is a perfectly good free option - it just needs recutting each spring and touching up through the season.
Nearly everything that goes wrong with landscape edging is in this table.
| What you see | Usually means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| A section standing higher than the rest after winter | Frost heave, or a stake that has loosened, rotted or was only ever in loose backfill | Tap the section down and drive a new, longer stake beside the old one into firm soil below the trench - below the frost-active layer where you can |
| Roll plastic rising in a wavy line | Heat expansion in summer and frost heave in winter ratchet it upward | Add stakes every 12 inches and bury more of its depth. If it has turned brittle, replace it |
| Metal edging rippling along its length | Gauge too light, or it was hammered on the top edge instead of through the stakes | Ripples won't press out. Replace those lengths with 14-gauge steel or heavier, or aluminum |
| A gap opening at a joint | Pieces butted instead of overlapped, or the connector has worked loose | Pull the pieces back together, overlap or connect them as the maker intends and restake at the joint |
| Grass creeping into the bed | The edge is too shallow or too low; Bermudagrass and zoysia also travel over the top by runners | Dig out the runners in the bed. If it happens every year, replace with edging buried 4-6 inches and standing about 1/2 inch above the soil, and trim runners regularly |
| A brick, paver or stone row tipping outward | No concrete haunch or restraint behind it, or the base has washed out or heaved | Lift the affected pieces, reset them on a firm base and support them with a concrete haunch kept below the finished soil |
| Wood gone soft at the ends | Unsealed cut ends, which soak up water from day one | Replace that board, sealing the cut ends of the new one before it goes in |
| A new puddle on one side of the edging | The edge is damming water that used to flow across the line | Give it a way through: remove a short section, open a joint, or swap part of the run for a permeable edge such as dry-laid stone |



Between them, these cover nearly everything an edge will ever need.
Tap the section back to the right height, with a scrap of wood on top to protect it. Then drive a new stake beside the old one rather than pounding the old one back in - its hole is enlarged and won't hold. In cold zones use a longer stake (12 to 18 inches) so it reaches firm soil well below the trench; the deeper it goes, the less frost can grip it.
Cut through the old board on either side of the rot with a handsaw instead of fighting the fasteners. Check the stakes while it is out and replace any that are soft at soil level. Cut the new ground-contact board to length, seal every cut end, and land the joints on a stake so both boards share it. Use exterior-rated screws or galvanized nails.
Rake out the failed joint about 1/2 inch deep with a joint raker or an old screwdriver, brush it clean and dampen it. Pack in a stiff premixed mortar, press it in well and strike it off flush. Keep it damp for a day or two in hot weather so it cures instead of drying out, and don't repoint when frost is expected within a couple of days.
Lift the loose brick, paver, cobble or curb piece right out. Clean off the old mortar or loose base, refill and tamp the base, then reset it to a string line and support the back with a concrete haunch kept below the finished soil. Pushing a loose piece back without fixing what is underneath just repeats the failure.
A quick test for each situation.
When you replace, fix the cause. Edging that fails early almost always failed for a reason that is still there: stakes in loose backfill, no base or haunch, light-gauge metal, unsealed cut ends, an edge too shallow for frost or for Bermudagrass, or an edge asked to hold back soil it was never built for. Put the same product back the same way and you get the same short life. Spend an extra twenty minutes doing the installation properly and the new edge will outlast the old one several times over.
It snags the mower, the mower pushes it further, and within two seasons the whole run is wandering.
The fixDeal with a raised section the week you spot it. At that stage it is a two-minute job.
The hole it pulled out of is enlarged, so it works loose again within months - often by the next thaw.
The fixDrive a new, longer stake beside it into firm soil below the trench.
The problem is the base or the support behind it, not the paver, so it rocks again by next spring.
The fixLift it, rebuild the base, reset it and support it properly.
A strip covered in mulch or soil isn't a mow strip any more, and grass roots straight into the covering.
The fixSweep it clear in spring and fall, and keep bed soil and mulch about 1 1/2 to 2 inches below its top.
Salt speeds up rust on steel and pits concrete curbing, and an auger or plow blade can bend a whole run along a driveway or walk.
The fixMark edging with snow stakes before winter, use sand or a gentler de-icer near it, and choose aluminum or stone where salt is unavoidable.
If it failed because it was understaked, too shallow or had no base, the new one fails the same way on the same timeline.
The fixWork out why it failed before buying the replacement, and correct the installation.
Twelve checks, about half an hour. Ticks are saved in this browser only.
Two forces work on it. Thin plastic expands in summer sun and shrinks at night, and in colder zones frost heave pushes it up every winter, so each cycle ratchets it a little further out of the ground until the run is wavy. The fix is more stakes - roughly one every 12 inches, about twice what the box suggests - and burying at least two thirds of its depth. If it has turned brittle and cracks when tapped, it is worn out and needs replacing.
Bermudagrass and zoysia spread both by underground rhizomes and by above-ground runners, so the edge has to block both: bury it 4 to 6 inches deep and leave it standing about 1/2 inch above the soil so runners can't simply step over. Then trim the runners that reach the edge every few weeks in summer, and dig out any that have rooted in the bed rather than just pulling the tops. Steel, aluminum and concrete curbing hold up best; thin plastic and loose stone let it through.
Wait until the ground has fully thawed, then tap the section back down with a rubber mallet and a block of wood. Drive a new, longer stake beside the old one into firm soil below the trench, rather than reusing the loosened hole. If the same run heaves every winter, it is too shallow or sitting in poorly drained soil: reinstall it deeper, on a few inches of compacted gravel, so water drains away from it instead of freezing around it.
Cut it properly with a half-moon edger once in spring, then touch it up with edging shears or a string trimmer every few weeks through the mowing season. In the South, where Bermudagrass and St. Augustine grow fast, that may mean a full recut two or three times a year. That is the trade with a cut edge: it is free and looks great, but it asks for that time forever, where hard edging asks once.
Usually there is nothing to fix. Weathering steel is meant to rust and stabilizes after two or three years, and surface rust on cut ends of coated steel is cosmetic. What can't be repaired is a rippled or kinked section, or steel that has rusted through near the coast or beside a salted walk - replace those lengths, ideally with heavier steel or with aluminum, which doesn't rust.
A rocking brick or paver almost always means the base underneath has washed out or heaved, or the concrete haunch or restraint behind it has failed or was never there. Lift the loose pieces completely, clean off old mortar, refill and tamp the base, reset them to a string line, and support the back with concrete kept below the finished soil. Pressing them back down without fixing the support just repeats the problem.
No. The preservative in pressure-treated lumber is inside the wood, and a surface coat on a board buried on one face and its bottom edge does very little. What matters is sealing every cut end with end-cut preservative when you cut it, because that is where water gets in. Expect about seven to ten years from a board, longer in dry climates, and replace boards individually as they go.
Repair isolated faults: a lifted section, one soft board, a failed mortar joint, a separated connector. Replace when the failure is built in - metal that has rippled, plastic that has turned brittle, wood soft along its whole length, curbing broken into heaved chunks, or an edge that frost lifts in the same place every spring. The other signal is time: if you are fixing the same edge more than once a year, replacing it costs less than your weekends.
A solid run of edging across a slope acts as a small dam, stopping water that used to sheet across the line, so it collects on the uphill side. Give the water a route: remove a short section at the low point, open a joint or two in a brick or stone run, or replace part of the line with a permeable edge such as dry-laid stone. If the whole area stays soggy, see Yard Drainage.