Walk the edging aisle at any home improvement store and you will find a dozen products that all promise a crisp lawn line. Underneath the packaging they come down to six families of material, and each one wins or loses on the same four things: how it looks, how long it lasts, how much fuss it needs and what it costs per foot. Here they are side by side, with the one table that usually ends the debate.
General guidance for American yards. Gauges, warranties and product specs differ from brand to brand, so read the spec sheet for what you are actually buying, and costs here are rough planning ranges that vary by region. Part of the PlantMapper Landscape Edging section.
Small pieces like cobblestones follow a curve that a straight board never will · photograph via Pexels
How to compare them
Looks, lifespan, upkeep and price rarely line up
The cheap edging really is cheap, the handsome edging really is pricey, and the right choice for most yards lands somewhere between. Judge every product on appearance, lifespan, upkeep and cost per linear foot, and accept up front that nothing scores top marks on all four.
Two more questions decide a lot in the US. First, will it bend? Wood boards, landscape timbers and precast concrete pieces only do straight lines; steel, aluminum, plastic and composite flex; brick, pavers and stone follow a curve only because you lay them one piece at a time. Second, will it survive your winters? In the northern half of the country, frost heave lifts anything that is shallow or poorly staked, and de-icing salt near a sidewalk or driveway eats some materials faster than others.
Each material is covered below, then compared in one table.
Material by material
The six edging materials, in detail
What each one is, where it fits and what living with it is really like.
Steel and aluminum
Higher cost
Thin strips, usually 4 to 6 inches deep, sold in straight or
flexible lengths with built-in or separate stakes. Installed flush with the soil they
almost vanish, leaving just a clean line between lawn and bed. Steel comes powder-coated
(black or green is common), galvanized, or as weathering steel (COR-TEN type) that
develops a deliberate rusty brown. Aluminum is lighter, never rusts and is the safer
pick for coastal yards and next to salted sidewalks.
Looks likeA line, not a product. Weathering steel shows as a warm brown band; black or green powder coat disappears against soil
Best forCurved beds, modern designs, lawn-to-bed edges, holding decomposed granite or gravel
Life20-40 years for steel; aluminum lasts indefinitely because it does not rust
UpkeepPractically none. Tap a section back down after a hard winter
Watch out forThin gauges kink when you drive the stakes - look for 14-gauge or heavier steel (1/8 in aluminum). Cut ends are sharp, so file or cap them
Wood and landscape timbers
Lowest cost
Pressure-treated 2x4 or 2x6 boards on stakes, or landscape timbers
where the edge also holds back a little soil. It is the least expensive rigid edging
you can buy, goes in with ordinary hand tools and fades from view once plants spill
over it. Cedar and redwood are untreated, naturally rot-resistant options. The catch:
wood only does straight lines.
Looks likeGreenish or honey-brown when new, weathering to silver-gray in two or three years
LifeAbout 7-10 years for a treated board, 10-20 for a ground-contact landscape timber
UpkeepSeal every cut end; otherwise leave it alone and plan to replace it eventually
Watch out forBuy lumber labeled for ground contact, not above-ground use. Stake it every 3-4 ft or it bows. Old creosote railroad ties don't belong in food gardens or play areas
Brick and pavers
Mid-high cost
Clay brick or concrete pavers set on edge, standing upright in a
"soldier" row, or laid flat as a mow strip. They go on a compacted gravel base, either
dry-laid with a buried restraint or set in mortar with a concrete haunch behind. Brick
is the natural partner for a brick house, a Colonial or a Craftsman, and laid flat and
level with the lawn it pays for itself in time saved trimming.
Looks likeIt can match your house, your patio or your walkway, which is the whole point
Best forTraditional homes, formal front yards, mow strips, edging a paver patio or walk
Life30-50 years and more; the mortar or base gives out long before the brick
UpkeepReset or repoint the odd piece every decade or so; scrub off moss in damp shade
Watch out forIn freeze-thaw country use paving brick or pavers rated for severe weathering, not soft salvaged wall brick, which flakes apart after a few winters
Natural stone
Highest cost
Granite cobblestones and Belgian block, cut bluestone or limestone
strips, or a row of fieldstone and river rock. It is the best-looking hard edge you can
install and, done well, it outlasts the house. Because cobbles are small they follow
curves as tightly as you like, which is why Belgian block lines so many curved
driveways in the Northeast.
Looks likeGray granite, blue-gray bluestone, buff limestone or local fieldstone; it only gets better with age and moss
Best forCurves, driveways, front yards, anywhere the edge is a feature rather than hidden
LifeEffectively permanent
UpkeepAlmost none; reset the odd stone after frost
Watch out forPrice and labor - every piece is set by hand. Reclaimed Belgian block varies in size and needs sorting. Loose fieldstone edging traps grass and is fiddly to trim
Concrete and curbing
Low-mid cost
Two forms. Precast concrete edgers - scalloped, straight or
"mower edge" pieces - are cheap, rot-proof and sold by the stack at every home store.
Poured or extruded concrete curbing is a continuous curb that a contractor shapes
on site with a curbing machine, often colored or stamped to look like stone. Curbing
follows any curve and is a very popular choice across the South and West. Plain gray
precast pieces can look utilitarian, but colored and textured products have come a long
way.
Looks likeGray, tan, red or charcoal; stamped curbing can pass for stone from a few feet away
Best forLong runs, driveways and walks that carry weight, low-maintenance yards, bold continuous lines
Life25-50 years for precast; curbing 20 years or more if the soil is stable
UpkeepLittle; reseal colored curbing every few years. It may green in shade
Watch out forCurbing can crack where frost heave or tree roots lift it, and it is hard to remove. Avoid flimsy scalloped pieces that tilt within a season
Plastic and composite
Lowest cost
Two very different products share a shelf. Thin roll-type plastic
edging (the coil with a rounded top bead) is the cheapest edging there is and acts like
it: it heaves, turns brittle and looks like plastic. Heavy-duty commercial-grade plastic
and composite boards made from recycled polymer and wood fiber are a different story -
rot-proof, semi-flexible and able to hold a curve. Make sure you know which one you are
buying.
Looks likeRoll plastic: obviously plastic. Composite: a believable wood board that never grays
Best forRoll plastic: temporary or hidden runs. Composite and heavy-duty plastic: curved beds, wet ground, no-maintenance yards
LifeRoll plastic about 3-8 years; composite 20-25 years
UpkeepNone for either, though roll edging needs pushing back down every spring
Watch out forRoll edging creeping out of the ground with summer heat and winter frost - stake it far more often than the box says
As an Amazon Associate, PlantMapper may earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are set by Amazon. Set edging flush with the soil at the lawn line, or clearly raised by 2 inches or more - anything in between catches the mower.
Head to head
The comparison table
The four things that decide it, plus whether the material will bend into a curve. The ratings are a practical judgment for a typical home yard, not lab results.
Landscape edging materials compared. Costs are very rough materials-only ranges per linear foot (curbing installed); prices vary widely by region and supplier.
Material
Appearance
Life
Upkeep
Cost per foot
Curves?
Steel / weathering steel
Nearly invisible, or a warm rusted band
20-40 years
None
$3-8
Yes - the best curved option
Aluminum
Nearly invisible; never rusts
30 years+
None
$3-8
Yes
Treated wood board
Grays with age; hides under plants
7-10 years
Seal cut ends
$2-5
No
Landscape timbers
Chunky and rustic
10-20 years
Seal cut ends
$2-6
No
Composite
A wood board that never weathers
20-25 years
None
$3-7
Gentle curves
Brick or pavers
Traditional; can match the house
30-50 years
Occasional resetting
$4-10
Yes, with cutting
Natural stone / Belgian block
The best-looking of all
Permanent
Almost none
$8-20+
Yes - tightest curves of any
Precast concrete edgers
Utilitarian unless well chosen
25-50 years
None
$2-6
Only gentle curves
Poured concrete curbing
Bold continuous line; can be stamped
20 years+
Reseal color
$8-15 installed
Yes
Roll plastic
Obviously plastic
3-8 years
Pushing it back down
$1-3
Yes, but it heaves
The short version. For a curved lawn-to-bed edge, steel is hard to beat - nearly invisible, lasts for decades, needs nothing and takes up no bed space. For a straight run on a small budget, a pressure-treated board does the same job for far less and you accept replacing it in about ten years. In a coastal yard or beside a salted walk, swap steel for aluminum. Everything else is a choice about looks.
Shape first
Which materials really bend into a curve
This knocks out about half the options before looks even come into it, so settle it early.
✓Truly flexible
Steel and aluminum strip - sold in flexible lengths; bends to a radius of roughly 3 ft.
Composite and heavy-duty plastic - sweeps into gentle curves, though not tight ones.
Roll plastic - the most flexible of all and the least satisfying in every other way.
Poured concrete curbing - formed in place, so it follows whatever line you paint on the ground.
Cobblestones, bricks and pavers - rigid on their own, but small enough to turn as tightly as you want.
A spade-cut edge - free, endlessly flexible and needs recutting a few times each season.
!Straight lines only
Wood boards and landscape timbers. Chopping them into short pieces to fake a curve almost never looks right.
Precast concrete edgers. Some allow a gentle sweep by opening the joints a little; nothing tighter.
Long cut-stone strips such as bluestone, as opposed to small cobbles.
Rigid 8 ft lumber and fence boards.
Anything sold in rigid 8 ft lengths - assume it is straight-line only unless the maker says it bends.
If your beds are curved but you have your heart set on wood, change the line rather than
the material: straight runs meeting at shallow angles read as deliberate geometry, while a
chopped-up curve reads as a failed one. Or use steel where the line bends and wood on the
straight stretches - a common pro approach that looks perfectly natural once plants soften
the joints.
The upgrade that pays you back
Mow strips
A mow strip is a flat band of hard material set level with the lawn, wide enough for a mower wheel to ride on. It saves more labor than anything else you can add to a lawn, so it is worth knowing about before you buy any edging at all.
What it does
Ends string trimming along that edge
One mower wheel rides on the strip, so the blade cuts the grass right to the line. Nothing is left to trim and there is no edge to recut each spring.
No string trimming along that edge, ever again
No yearly recutting with a half-moon edger
The bed keeps its shape instead of slowly creeping
Plants can spill over it without the mower chopping them
How wide
6-10 inches
Wide enough that the mower wheel stays on it easily without careful steering.
6 inches is the practical minimum - roughly one paver laid crosswise
8-10 inches is comfortable and looks generous rather than skimpy
Two rows of brick or a 12-inch paver cut down both give a good width
What to make it from
Brick, pavers, stone or concrete
It carries a mower and must not shift, so set it on a compacted gravel base, either in mortar or locked in with a restraint.
Brick or pavers laid flat is the classic, and usually the cheapest
Cobblestones for a tight curve or more texture
Poured concrete curbing with a flat mower edge for a continuous strip
Not wood or roll plastic - they will not stay level under a mower wheel
The height
Flush, or a hair low
If the strip sits proud the whole benefit is lost, because the mower rides up and scalps the grass beside it.
Set it level with the soil at the base of the grass, or about 1/8 to 1/4 inch below
Allow for new sod settling in its first year - err on the low side
Slope it very slightly toward the bed so water doesn't sit on it
Making the call
A quick route to the right material
Read down until one line describes your yard.
The edging most likely to suit each situation.
If this sounds like your yard…
The likely answer
A curved lawn edge you want to disappear
Steel or aluminum, set flush
A straight run on a tight budget
Pressure-treated board rated for ground contact, on stakes
You never want to string trim that edge again
A brick or paver mow strip laid flat and level
A traditional brick house or a formal front yard
Brick on edge, or Belgian block
Holding in a gravel or decomposed granite path
Steel or aluminum for a walkway, stone or concrete where a car drives over it
A vegetable garden or raised beds
Untreated cedar or landscape timbers - cheap, replaceable, and the edge is the structure
Bermudagrass or zoysia lawn creeping into beds
Deep steel, aluminum or concrete curbing, plus regular trimming of runners
A coastal yard or an edge next to a salted sidewalk
Aluminum, composite or stone
Wet ground where wood rots quickly
Composite or aluminum
You will never maintain it and never want to think about it again
Steel or aluminum if the budget allows, composite if not
A rental, or a layout you may change in a few years
Wood board, or just a crisp spade-cut edge
Shopping mistakes
Six ways to buy the wrong edging
1. Buying flimsy metal edging
Light-gauge steel kinks as you drive the stakes and ripples along the run afterward, which looks worse than no edging.
The fixChoose 14-gauge steel or heavier (or 1/8 in aluminum), and check the listed gauge rather than trusting the photo.
2. Expecting roll plastic to stay put
Thin plastic expands in summer, shrinks in the cold and gets pushed up by frost, so within two seasons it stands proud in a wavy line.
The fixSpend a little more on heavy-duty plastic or composite, or stake roll edging about every 12 inches.
3. Using salvaged wall brick
Soft old house brick isn't made to sit in wet soil; where winters freeze it flakes and crumbles after a few seasons.
The fixUse clay paving brick or concrete pavers rated for severe weathering.
4. Choosing wood for curves
Boards cut into short lengths give a jagged line that reads as a mistake rather than a design.
The fixUse metal where the line bends, or redraw the curve as straight runs meeting at shallow angles.
5. Buying above-ground treated lumber
The cheaper "above ground" grade isn't meant to sit in soil, and an edging board is buried on one face and its bottom edge.
The fixBuy lumber labeled for ground contact, and seal every cut end before it goes in.
6. Buying on looks alone for a working edge
Loose fieldstone across a wheelbarrow route will scatter; thin plastic holding back gravel or decomposed granite will bow.
The fixMatch the material to the job first, then pick the best-looking option that will survive it.
For a lawn-to-bed edge, especially a curved one, steel is hard to beat: set flush it nearly disappears, lasts for decades, needs no care and takes up no bed space. Aluminum does the same with no rust, which makes it the better pick near the coast or beside a salted walk. For a straight run on a budget, a pressure-treated board rated for ground contact costs far less, though expect to replace it in about ten years. If you want to stop trimming that edge for good, a brick or paver mow strip beats them all.
Is metal edging better than plastic?
Yes, by a wide margin, and the price gap reflects it. Steel and aluminum hold a true line for decades, bend into proper curves and stay where you put them. Thin roll plastic swells in summer heat, shrinks in the cold, gets lifted by frost heave and turns brittle, so after a few seasons it is standing proud in a wavy line. Heavy-duty plastic and composite edging sit in the middle: much better than roll plastic, cheaper than metal.
What edging is best for curved flower beds?
Steel or aluminum strip, which bends to a radius of about 3 feet and stays nearly invisible. Poured concrete curbing also follows any curve and is a popular installed option. Cobblestones, bricks and pavers curve beautifully because they are small pieces set one at a time, but they cost more in materials and labor. Wood boards, landscape timbers and most precast concrete pieces are straight-line materials.
Does wood edging need to be treated?
Yes, if it is ordinary lumber: buy pressure-treated wood labeled for ground contact, not above-ground use, and brush end-cut preservative onto every cut before it goes in. Painting or staining the faces later does little, because the protection in treated lumber is inside the wood. Cedar and redwood resist rot naturally and are a good untreated choice for vegetable beds. Steel, aluminum, composite, brick, stone and concrete need no treatment at all.
How long does landscape edging last?
Roughly: roll plastic three to eight years; treated wood boards seven to ten; landscape timbers ten to twenty; composite twenty to twenty-five; steel twenty to forty; concrete curbing twenty or more; brick and pavers thirty to fifty; and natural stone effectively forever. In cold zones, how well it is anchored against frost heave matters as much as the material, and most edging is replaced because it has moved or the design changed rather than because it wore out.
What is a mow strip and is it worth it?
A flat band of brick, pavers, stone or concrete set level with the soil at the lawn edge and wide enough for a mower wheel to ride on, usually 6 to 10 inches. The blade cuts right to the line, so there is no string trimming and no yearly edge recutting. It costs more than strip edging to install, but in a yard you plan to stay in it pays you back in a few summers of saved weekends.
Is aluminum or steel edging better near the coast?
Aluminum. Salt air, and de-icing salt splashed from sidewalks and driveways, speed up corrosion on steel, especially at cut ends and scratches in the coating. Aluminum does not rust, is lighter to handle and costs about the same as good steel. Composite, stone and concrete are also unaffected by salt.
What edging should I use to hold in gravel or decomposed granite?
Something rigid that stands about 1 1/2 to 2 inches above the finished surface. Steel and aluminum are ideal because they are thin and strong; pressure-treated boards and brick also work well. Avoid thin roll plastic, which bows under the sideways push of stone. Angular crushed stone and decomposed granite stay put far better than round pea gravel, whatever you edge them with.